In Depth Analysis: CalculatedRisk Newsletter on Real Estate (Ad Free) Read it here.

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Fannie Mae's Berson: House Prices to Fall

by Calculated Risk on 2/07/2007 04:50:00 PM

"Real home-price gains, adjusted for inflation, will be negative this year, next year and possibly the year after that."
David Berson, Fannie Mae Chief Economist, Feb 7, 2007
From MarketWatch: Housing still on down slope
"I don't think we've seen the bottom," said David Berson, chief economist for Fannie Mae. "We're going to see a much bigger drop in investor demand this year. But by the second half of the year the market will stabilize, if investors pull out quickly."

Berson said he expects the home-price index calculated by the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight will show a nationwide decline in values for 2007, the first time that will have happened since the data began being collected in 1975. Unlike other measures, the OFHEO data measure the price changes on the same homes over time, meaning the index is less likely to be skewed by the types and locations of sales.

"It won't be a big decline, maybe 1%. And the declines will be far more centered in areas that have had the most investor activity," he said. "Real home-price gains, adjusted for inflation, will be negative this year, next year and possibly the year after that."
My forecast that "prices will fall nominally by 1% to 3% nationwide" is similar to Berson's.

Here are a few more recent forecasts:

Home prices will fall 10% on average in 2007
UBS analyst Margaret Whelan, Nov 6, 2006
"We believe nationwide home prices -- as measured by the federal OFHEO repeat sales index -- will be roughly unchanged in 2007. ... The risk to our price forecast is to the downside."
Saumil Parikh, PIMCO Portfolio Manager, Dec 27, 20062007
"Whether prices go down or stay the way they are, you can pretty much guarantee that whatever the value of your house now, that's going to be the value of your house in 2011."
Dr. Christopher Thornberg, October 19, 2006
"I expect at least a 20% decline in median single-family house prices nationwide, and that number may be way understated."
A. Gary Shilling, August 29, 2006, for the entire bust, not 2007.
[Orange County] house prices this year will increase 7 percent
Broker Gary Watts, Feb 7, 2007