by Calculated Risk on 7/11/2009 05:50:00 PM

The WSJ Real Time Economics blog mentioned Okun's law yesterday (a relationship between changes in GDP and unemployment): Job Losses Outpace GDP Decline (ht Bob_in_MA)

In a research note, [Alliance Bernstein economist Joseph] Carson says job losses in prior downturns have been roughly proportional to the decline in gross domestic product. But in the current recession, the proportion of jobs lost is running about a third greater than the drop in real GDP.

The correlation between GDP growth and unemployment is called Okun’s Law, after the late economist Arthur Okun who documented it in the 1960s. But the numerical relationship that Okun estimated – and other economists have since refined – has broken down. His original estimate suggested about a 3% decline in GDP for every 1% increase in unemployment. Before joining the Fed, Ben Bernanke, working with Andrew Abel, figured more recent suggested about a 2% decrease in output for every 1% increase in unemployment.

Click on graph for larger image.

This graph shows the quarterly change in real GDP (annualized) vs. the change in unemployment rate. The red markers are for 2008 and Q1 2009.

Usually the trend line is drawn as linear, but I made it a 2nd order polynomial here.

The red markers are above the trend line, but within the normal scatter.

For Q2 the unemployment rate increased 1.2% (from Q1, quarterly average), and the annualized real GDP change will probably be in the -1% to -2% range - so that is also above the trend (a larger than expected change in unemployment based on the change in real GDP).

Okun's law is just a general relationship, and the relationship appears to have changed over time (as mentioned in the WSJ).

Note: the graph shows the quarterly change in real GDP annualized (the way it is reported by the BEA each quarter). In the WSJ post, they mentioned "a 2% [or 3%] decrease in output for every 1% increase in unemployment". A 2% decrease in quarterly output would be reported by the BEA as over 8% annualized for the quarter.

by Calculated Risk on 7/11/2009 01:41:00 PM

From the SF Gate: State leaders talking again - budget woes go on

California's fiscal crisis continued unabated Friday with most major banks refusing to cash the state's IOUs starting today, the state controller delaying $4 billion in payments to public schools ...

State Controller John Chiang and state Superintendent of Instruction Jack O'Connell said $4 billion in payments to local school districts that were supposed to go out on Friday will be delayed until July 30. The move will conserve cash for the state, which has been issuing IOUs since July 2. ...

As of Friday morning, the state controller had mailed 101,930 IOUs covering more than $389 million in payments, said Hallye Jordan, a spokeswoman for Chiang.

And despite a plea from state Treasurer Bill Lockyer that banks extend their Friday deadline to accept the IOUs, most refused to do so.

Citibank agreed to a one-week extension, while Bank of the West said it will accept IOUs until further notice. The banks that rejected extension requests include Bank of America, Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Chase and Union Bank ...

And Felix Salmon has a nice chart on who gets paid cash, and who gets IOUs: California: The haves and have-nots

And from Controller John Chiang yesterday: Controller Releases Year-End Cash Figures

“California continues to pay for its history of unbalanced budgets. The State spent $10.4 billion more than it collected last year alone, and is now without enough cash to cover all of its payment obligations,” said Chiang.

“Our major sources of revenue have continued their trend downward, leaving no viable option but to craft a new budget that recognizes California’s recovery has yet to begin.”

Personal income taxes in June were $987 million below (-18.0%) estimates in the May Revision, and sales taxes were short by $154 million (-5.8%). Corporate taxes were $1.31 billion above estimates (41.2%). Corporate taxes in May and June were boosted by a surge of payments from corporate taxpayers hoping to avoid a new State penalty.

The State started the fiscal year with a $1.45 billion cash deficit, which grew to $11.9 billion on June 30, 2009. Borrowed money from special funds provided enough cash to fund State operations through June 30. The Controller faced a large cash shortfall at the end of July, forcing his office to begin issuing registered warrants or “IOUs” to any General Fund payment that was not protected by the State Constitution, federal law, or court decision. Without IOUs, the State would have run out of cash and begun missing those protected payments at the end of July.

While updated cash projections show that IOUs will preserve enough cash to make those protected payments through September, the cash shortfall in October will endanger the State’s ability to make those payments.

Many other states have serious budget problems too.

by Calculated Risk on 7/11/2009 09:03:00 AM

A little Saturday morning video ... offered without comment.

Bloomberg - Roubini Says U.S. Recession Will Last Six More Months (Click here for full video)

00:00 Outlook for the U.S. economy, recession
07:07 Reasons for current economic condition
11:50 Unemployment rate; fiscal consolidation
18:29 Case-Shiller Index; green shoots in housing
30:05 Second stimulus package; consumer spending
34:43 Roubini, Shiller respond to questions.

Here is a short preview ...

by Calculated Risk on 7/11/2009 01:09:00 AM

CIT Group (no relation to Citigroup) is like GE Capital. They provide financing for almost 1 million businesses and had about 76 billion in assets as of March 31st.

From the WSJ: Major Lender Faces Crunch

CIT Group Inc ... is preparing for a possible bankruptcy filing ... CIT has retained the law firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, ...
...
CIT has a $1 billion payment due in mid-August and it is unclear the company "will be able to handle that," said this person. The company will give more guidance when it discusses second quarter earnings in two weeks.
...
A bankruptcy filing by CIT could affect thousands of small borrowers, from Dunkin' Donuts franchisees to restaurant owners and clothing retailers.

... the government has made it clear it doesn't see the company as a systemic risk to the financial system. The people familiar with the matter said the government feels that other lenders, such as J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. or Deutsche Bank AG, can handle many of the same loans that CIT specializes in, such as loans to small retailers or rail-car leasing firms.

Meanwhile, competitors like GE Capital Corp. and GMAC LLC have been able to sell debt with the backing of the government's top credit rating.

Apparently the government thinks CIT's competitors could pick up most or all of their business.

by Calculated Risk on 7/10/2009 10:12:00 PM

Just using Sacramento as an example ... I wish the NAR broke out the data like this!

Click on graph for larger image in new window.

The Sacramento Association of REALTORS® is now breaking out monthly resales by equity sales (normal resales), and distressed sales (Short sales and REO sales). Here is the June data.

They started breaking out REO sales last year, but this is the first monthly report with short sales.

Just over 70% of all resales (single family homes and condos) were distressed sales.

Total sales in June were off 7% compared to June 2008, and that breaks a string of YoY increases.

This is just a reminder - with 70% distressed sales, there will be few move-up buyers for the higher priced areas.