by Calculated Risk on 2/25/2009 11:06:00 PM

Another summary post and open thread (for discussion).

Existing home sales in January 2009 (4.49 million SAAR) were 5.4% lower than last month, and were 8.6% lower than January 2008 (4.91 million SAAR). See link for graphs of sales and inventory.

The Treasury announced the Capital Assistance Program today. The detail can be found on the Treasury site: http://www.financialstability.gov/. This included the stress test economic scenarios. Here is the table of the scenarios and graphs of what this means in terms of house prices.

Bernanke testified before the House Financial Services Committee today. Basically he repeated his Senate testimony, but he did argue that progress has been made. Here are some Credit Crisis indicators that suggest that is correct.

And oh yeah, the WSJ is reporting the Citi Deal Is Imminent.

by Calculated Risk on 2/25/2009 08:49:00 PM

Here is our daily "Citi deal is imminent" story.

From the WSJ: Citi Is Near Deal to Boost U.S.'s Stake by Up to 40%

Citigroup Inc. is closing in on an agreement to boost the federal government's stake in the company to as much as 40%, according to people familiar with the situation. A deal could be announced as soon as Thursday.

This could raise some interesting problems in foreign countries:

For example, a Mexican law bars any institution that is more than 10%-owned by a foreign government from running a bank in that country. As a result, some Citigroup executives are worried that an increased U.S. stake might subject the bank to pressure to relinquish some or all of its ownership of Grupo Financiero Banamex ...

UPDATE: This happened twice today. One government release says one thing, another says something different. I noted that the Treasury White Paper on the Capital Assistance Program said:

These shares can convert at the firm’s discretion (with the approval of their regulator) into common equity if needed to preserve lending in worse-than-expected economic environment at a conversion price set at a 10% discount from the prevailing level of the institution’s stock price as of February 9, 2009.

Nemo notes that the Term Sheet says:

Conversion price is 90% of the average closing price for the common stock for the 20 trading day period ending February 9, 2009, subject to customary anti-dilution adjustments.

One release from the FDIC called the program the "Capital Assessment Program" (and I labeled a couple of charts with that name), but the real name is the "Capital Assistance Program".

by Calculated Risk on 2/25/2009 06:15:00 PM

Form Bloomberg: Lewis Says Merrill, Countrywide Are ‘Stars’ This Year

Bank of America Corp. Chief Executive Officer Kenneth Lewis said Merrill Lynch & Co. and Countrywide Financial Corp., the acquisitions that some analysts say helped push down the bank’s share price, have been “stars” so far this year.

At first glance this seems absurd. One analyst is quoted in the story saying "I almost fell off my chair". However if you separate the acquired toxic assets from the ongoing performance, I can understand Lewis' comments. Countrywide is benefiting from the refinance boom. Most (if not all) of these loans are being sold to Fannie and Freddie (or guaranteed by them).

The key question is how toxic are the toxic assets BofA acquired with Merrill and Countrywide? Oh well, the Capital Assistance Program is here to help.

by Calculated Risk on 2/25/2009 03:59:00 PM

Here are a couple of graphs to illustrate the Capital Assistance Program house price scenarios. (see previous post) Note: the FDIC called it Capital Assessment Program (so the graph titles are incorrect!)

Click on graph for larger image in new window.

For whatever reason the Treasury is using the Case-Shiller Composite 10 index (I'd prefer the National Index). This graph shows nominal house prices under the two scenarios: baseline, and more severe.

Under the baseline scenario, nominal prices in the Composite 10 cities would return to mid-2002 prices. Under the more severe scenario, prices would return to early 2001 prices.

The second graph shows what this would mean for the price-to-rent ratio.

Note: this is price-to-rent for the Composite 10 index and Jan 2000 is set to 1.0.

This assumes rents stay flat for the next two years (recent reports suggest rents are falling - and that would mean prices would have to fall further).

This metric suggests that the severe price declines would bring the price-to-rent ratio below the normal range. Note: this requires the above assumption on rents.

NOTE: This is based on the Composite 10 index, and that index will most likely decline more than the national index. Even in these 10 cities, some areas will probably see larger price declines (as an example areas with significant Option ARM loans) and other areas less.

Repeating this table of the scenarios:

by Calculated Risk on 2/25/2009 02:42:00 PM

According to the Supervisory Capital Assessment Program FAQs, the Stress Tests will be completed "as soon as possible" but no later than the end of April.

Here are the economic scenarios for the stress tests:

Click on table for larger image in new window.

The more severe case is a 22% decline in house prices in 2009 and a 7% decline in 2010 (using the Case-Shiller Composite 10). I'll put up a graph with these projections soon.