by Calculated Risk on 7/02/2005 12:00:00 AM

Many housing commentators have been looking to the UK and Australia housing markets as leading indicators for the US housing market. Now the housing bust may have reached the US shores: Boston is looking peaked.

In Massachusetts, the number of home sales dropped last month: Mass. home sales plunge 11.1 percent

There were about 36,259 homes on the market last month, or a supply of 8.8 months, a figure generally thought to be favorable to buyers, experts said.

That is worth repeating; the supply of existing homes is now 8.8 months in Massachusetts. And that is exactly how many commentators felt the bubble would end:

Economists say this combination - higher prices amid lower sales volume - is precisely what you'd see in a bubble that's dying.

And what happens when buyers use excessive leverage and can't sell? Massachusetts Foreclosure Filings Jump As Values Soar

Because of high housing prices, many first-time homebuyers have been using new, risky mortgage products that hold down costs in the early years of a loan, but they can face difficulties if payments rise later. In addition, people who already own homes have been tapping into rising property values to borrow money at historically low interest rates for college tuition, home improvements, credit-card debt, or other financial needs.

"When you tie all these factors together - the bubble in the real estate market, the popularity of interest-only loans, the willingness of lenders to give loans without a significant down payment, the lowering of standards for lenders, and the deep desire of people to own something priced beyond their means - you have a recipe for disaster," said Secretary of State William F. Galvin, whose office oversees the registries of deeds in a majority of the state's 14 counties. "That's what you're seeing in the Land Court."

And finally a quote from Bill Gross from Saturday's New York Times:

"... if housing prices stop going up, which would be my forecast, that makes a substantial difference. Individuals have banked on that appreciation every year. You should come to a point where owners of houses realize we're in never-never land and stop buying on a speculative basis. Markets many times fall of their own weight. That's what happened with the Nasdaq in 2000."

And maybe that's what is happening in Boston. Should we sound the alarm? The British Bust is coming!

by Calculated Risk on 7/01/2005 01:19:00 AM

The Orange County Register reports on a presentation by Wells Fargo's chief economist Scott Anderson at the Westin South Coast Plaza on Wednesday. The Register quotes Anderson:

"We're talking about a decade at least – if not more – of (housing price) stagnation,"

"There will be a slow fizzle (in prices), not a pop,"

Still Anderson is fairly positive:

There's a little oomph left in the market, he said. Anderson predicts that 30-year, fixed mortgage rates will remain around 5.8 percent over the next six months, which could help boost home prices about 5 percent this year. Next year, homeowners might see a 1 percent to 2 percent increase in appreciation, then Anderson expects prices will level off indefinitely until incomes can catch up.

Even though much of Orange County's economic recovery can be attributed to the housing boom, Anderson doesn't think stagnant housing prices spell recession, because strength will remain in other sectors like technology and tourism.

Previous housing booms also fizzled. But ten years of nominal price stagnation would be a 30% decline in real terms.

I'm less confident than Mr. Anderson about avoiding a recession.

by Calculated Risk on 6/30/2005 11:37:00 PM

On Tuesday night, CNN's Newsnight with Aaron Brown had a segment on the housing bubble. Here are excerpts from the transcript:

BROWN: Back in the mid '90s, when we were all thinking of early retirement after our Internet stocks tacked on another 10 or 15 points, there were naysayers who said it wouldn't last, who said rationality always returns eventually, who said it was a bubble and a dangerous one at that. Oh, those naysayers.

By the way, are you counting on home equity to fund your retirement? Like the fact that your home doubled in the last decade or so? Feeling rich again? So is this deja vu with a mortgage? Here's CNN's Andy Serwer.

(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE)

ANDY SERWER, CNN CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): Is there a housing bubble? It depends who you ask and where you ask.

DEAN BAKER, CTR FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH: Well, there's absolutely a housing bubble. In the last seven or eight years, we've seen an unprecedented run-up in home prices nationwide.

SERWER: No question, certain markets are red hot. Since 2000, the price of a single family home has jumped 77 percent in New York City, 92 percent in Miami, and 105 percent in San Diego. And there are other signs besides just home prices, 86 books on real estate investing were published last year, nearly three times as many as 1998.

Speculators have added fuel to overheated markets. In Los Angeles, for example, the number of homes sold that have been owned for less than six months jumped 47 percent in a year.

Prices are so high in some areas that renting a home has become dirt cheap by comparison. In San Francisco, for example, rent on a median price house runs $1,532 a month. Owning the same house with a typical mortgage would cost $3,424 a month.

But not every market is on fire. Some experts say that bubbles are mostly in cities on the east and west coasts. If those bubbles were to burst, it would shock the entire economy. But some say prices won't collapse, they'll just ease up.

FRANK NOTHAFT, CHIEF ECONOMIST, FREDDIE MAC: As long as the local economy remains strong and there is good job creation, then we're not going to see a drop in home values.

SERWER: In cities such as Dallas or Salt Lake or Pittsburgh, prices haven't risen nearly so much. Radical differences in prices can make moving from a hot zone like LA to a colder one like Syracuse either a windfall or a slap in the face, depending on which way you're going.

So what does all this mean for the prospective buyer?

FRANK NOTHAFT: It's a very personal decision whether or not they should sell now and choose to rent. If you're happy with your home and you enjoy the home that you're in and the neighborhood you're in, there's no point to sell it right now and switch to renting.

SERWER: In other words, don't just buy a home because you think you'll make a ton of money on it in two years. And don't sell your home just because it's appreciated wildly either. Because in real estate, as in everything else in life, you can't count on getting a better deal down the road.

Andy Serwer, CNN, New York.

(END VIDEOTAPE)

BROWN: Taking the global view for a moment, globalization being the rage these days, in 2004, housing prices in Spain and France went up even faster than they did here in the United States, 15 percent up for the year. Compared to 9 percent nationwide in the U.S.

But before you bet the farm, or the house, consider this. In Japan, house prices have dropped for the last 14 years. And they are now down 40 percent from their peak back in 1991. Here at home again, the median price of a house is $207,000. That means half the houses cost more, half the houses cost less.

There is more, but that was the most in-depth part of the discussion. Dean Baker didn't get much face time!

Any economic topic is difficult for TV News. No pictures. I can imagine the viewers reaching for the remote ... hmmm, any shark attacks today?

by Calculated Risk on 6/30/2005 09:21:00 PM

Following are some comments and stories from the Reuters Real Estate Summit in New York.

Property guru says U.S. market nearing peak Peter Korpacz, the head of real estate business advisory services for PriceWaterhouseCoopers told reporters:

"The thing the industry is focusing on now is jobs growth. For the most part its running at about 175,000 a month. It's a healthy economy, but it's not robust. During this point in the last recovery (in the early 1990s) jobs were growing at about 217,000 a month."

Korpacz said real estate lenders and developers are far more disciplined now than in the past and so there was little threat to the market from speculative development, although the red-hot residential sector was giving rise to concerns among investors.

He added that if there is a major drop in prices for condos or single-family housing, it could hurt "real estate as a whole and just wash (away) the whole industry."

Toll Bros sees possible correction in hot markets

"In the hot markets, I wouldn't be surprised to see a 20 percent decline," [Robert Toll Brothers Inc.'s chief executive] said at the Reuters Real Estate Summit in New York. "You've got a price going from $1 million to $800,000, I don't have a problem with that.

"I don't think you're going to have a pop, which means I don't think you've got a bubble," added the head of the luxury home builder at the summit held at Reuters U.S. headquarters in New York. "But I do think you're going to have a correction as the markets unnaturally overheat because of speculation."

For more stories see the Reuters Summit site.

by Calculated Risk on 6/30/2005 01:31:00 PM

An an undergrad, I was incredibly fortunate to take Chemistry from Drs.Sherwood Rowland and Mario Molina. At that time, the future Nobel Laureates (1995 Nobel Prize in Chemistry) Rowland and Molina were working on their ground breaking discoveries into how chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) were impacting the ozone.

But Rowland and Molina's work was just the start. To correct the CFC caused ozone depletion problem it took a combination of great science, an open discussion of the environmental impact of various policy options, government action and international cooperation. Not only was the chemistry fascinating, but that was my introduction into market failures and externalities. When I spoke with Dr. Rowland a few months ago, he modestly told me the science might have been the easy part!

With that prelude, here is a new Environmental Economics blog with 17 contributing economists addressing many of the economic and political issues that are required to transform good science into good policy. Enjoy!