by Calculated Risk on 6/20/2005 12:05:00 AM

My most recent post is up on Angry Bear - Housing: Bubble Talk.

UPDATE: I added this to my AB post: The WSJ (Greg Ip) has a front page article this morning: Booming Local Housing Markets Weigh Heavily on Overall Sector (pay): A few quotes:

New federal housing data show that the nation's most overheated local housing markets now make up such a large share of the total U.S. market that a sharp fall in their values could stall or slow national economic growth.
...
"It's a widespread boom and has macro implications," says Richard Brown, chief economist of the FDIC. "A slowdown would not only hurt these markets, but the U.S. as a whole."
...
Unlike stocks, the housing market "would be more likely flat with 10% to 20% declines in some regions, or down slightly nationally with some regions looking ugly," says Ethan Harris, chief U.S. economist at Lehman Brothers. Even local housing crashes take years to unfold, he says.

Also see WSJ: Fannie Sees Higher Odds of Regional Busts

ORIGINAL POST:

A couple of interesting facts about the San Diego market: First, here is an interactive graph showing the number of condos in the downtown San Diego market by week. There has been a surge in listings downtown.

And the last few paragraphs in this article indicate the job market is slowing down for housing related jobs in San Diego.

Phil Blair, a co-owner of the San Diego offices of Manpower, said construction firms are gearing up for continued growth. In a survey asking local companies about their hiring activity over the next three months, construction firms were the most optimistic that they would be adding new staff.

Blair said that financial and real estate firms were among the least optimistic, with some firms planning to lay off employees.

"Usually construction and real estate go together, but not this time around," he said. "I don't know if that means that there's some sort of a lag between one industry and the other or if the real estate people are beginning to worry that a bubble has burst."

He added that with real estate purchasing and mortgage applications slowing, there is less demand for work in those industries.

Construction firms are hiring, but real estate and financing firms are cutting back. Is the bubble ending?

by Calculated Risk on 6/19/2005 03:37:00 AM

The London Sunday Times asks: Is the global housing bubble set to burst?

As glittering spires continue to rise around the world and buyers still dream of escape to idylls in the sun, the questions grow more pressing. What has driven the boom? Has globalisation changed the law of gravity? Can the vertiginous ascent continue? Or is the biggest pop ever heard about to deflate the global property bubble and take the world economy down with it?

The Times does not completely answer the question. They do argue that stagnation is more likely than a crash. But price stagnation might lead to recession, and a recession might cause lower house prices leading to a deeper recession - a vicious cycle.

Perhaps their real opinion can be gleaned from their choice of companion pieces: Booms Past.

TULIP MANIA 1634

In Holland the craze for collecting tulips peaked in 1636 when investors paid more than 5,000 florins — about £25,000 at today’s prices — for a single bulb. But when buyers dried up, prices plummeted.

SOUTH SEA BUBBLE 1711

The vogue for public companies in the early 1800s produced the South Sea Company, which was granted a monopoly over trade to North America. But the bubble burst in September 1720 when banks could not collect loans on inflated stock.

1929

In the 1920s technological change saw the Dow Jones rise sevenfold, prompting investors to stake their life savings on the stock market. Interest rates rose, Wall Street panicked and by November 1929 two-thirds the Dow’s value had gone.

LAWSON BOOM

House prices in Britain soared in the late 1980s, buoyed by low interest rates and tax cuts. When interest rates doubled in 18 months house prices crashed, dropping by 30%-40% in some areas.

DOTCOM BUBBLE

In the 1990s internet stocks boomed. But after peaking in spring 2000 they lost two-thirds of their value in three years. Many firms vanished.

For a great summary of previous bubbles, I recommend "Extraordinary Popular Delusions And The Madness Of Crowds", By Charles MacKay, 1841.

by Calculated Risk on 6/17/2005 09:04:00 PM

Financial Times: EU crisis as Britain rejects deal on budget

Excerpt:

The European Union was plunged into political crisis on Friday night after Britain led the way in blocking a proposed deal on the new seven-year budget.

Tony Blair, the UK prime minister, was one of a minority of leaders who refused to accept a compromise package, as the Brussels summit collapsed in acrimony shortly before midnight. The failure of the talks means the transfer of billions of euros of aid to former communist countries in eastern Europe, due to start on January 1 2007, may be delayed.

The political ramifications of the breakdown, coming after French and Dutch voters rejected the EU constitution, could be severe.

This is another serious setback for the EU and is not good for America. A European Union in disarray and possibly entering recession will likely exacerbate the global imbalances and probably lead to larger US trade and current account deficits.

See Dr. Serser's 6.4% of GDP current account deficit in q1

General Glut's 6.4% AND GROWING

See Dr. Altig's The EU Divide and more.

by Calculated Risk on 6/16/2005 06:04:00 PM

Last month I started building a simple model to help forecast the monthly trade deficit. A review of the partial forecast showed some promise.

So here we go for May starting with oil. Using the same model (described here) the ERPP trade numbers for May are forecast to be:

IMPORTS: Energy Related Petroleum Products.
Barrels Crude: 337.9 million barrels.
Barrels Other ERPP: 85.0 million barrels.
DOE Price per barrel (Crude): $43.90
DOE Price per barrel (Other): $50.48

Preliminary - Total NSA ERRP Imports: $19.1 Billion

NOTE: The BLS reports petroleum import prices fell 6.5% in May from April. The above model used DOE prices. After reviewing the prior prices and comparing the DOE and BLS approaches, the DOE has been slightly more accurate. However, I think it might be even better to try to split the difference. The BLS approach would predict P(crude) = $41.85. DOE P(crude) = $43.90. So the modified forecast for Imports NSA is:

BLS/DOE Price per barrel (Crude): $42.88
BLS/DOE Price per barrel (Other): $49.31
Forecast: Total NSA ERRP Imports: $18.7 Billion

Total ERPP FORECAST:
Imports SA: $17.4 Billion (seasonal factor estimated at 0.93 for May)
Exports SA: $1.9 Billion
Balance ERPP: $15.5 Billion

by Calculated Risk on 6/16/2005 02:57:00 AM

UPDATE: I've been notified that "Housing Links" will not be continued. He recommends these two sites:

Patrick's Housing Links

RGEMonitor Housing Market Bubble?


I've been directed to a new housing resource: Housing Links. This site is a running compendium of stories, commentary and analysis on all aspects of the housing market. Here are some recent examples:

UPDATE2: In the comments, Stephane Grenier directs us to his interesting article "Is There Really a Real Estate Bubble?". He references me!

UPDATE: Two new stories in The Economist about the perils of the housing boom / pending bust: In come the waves (Great Graphs) and After the fall.

The Trillion-Dollar Bet - The NY Times looks at the widespread use of Adjustable Rate Mortgages:

This year, only about $80 billion, or 1 percent, of mortgage debt will switch to an adjustable rate based largely on prevailing interest rates, according to an analysis by Deutsche Bank in New York. Next year, some $300 billion of mortgage debt will be similarly adjusted.

But in 2007, the portion will soar, with $1 trillion of the nation's mortgage debt - or about 12 percent of it - switching to adjustable payments, according to the analysis.

The Mortgage Trap - BusinessWeek "Lenders are cranking out an ever-growing array of financing schemes and lowering standards to keep the housing boom going":

All those innovative mortgage products are a sure sign that lenders are doing everything they can to keep the housing boom going and to capitalize on yet another round of falling interest rates that no one expected. There are plenty of other signs of frenzy as well. Home appraisers complain that mortgage originators are demanding the optimistic appraisals needed to close on loans. "They started warning me to 'be a team player' and to 'hit the number' they needed to seal the deal," says Robert Burnitt, an appraiser in Midlothian, Tex.

And some positive stories:

Purchase Activity at Record High; Refinance Volume Jumps In Latest Application Survey - The Mortgage Bankers Association reports their "seasonally-adjusted Purchase Index increased by 10.4 percent to 529.3, a record high":

"This week there was a combination of record-setting purchase activity as well as a substantial pickup in refinance applications, with the refinance index at its highest level since April 2004," said Michael Fratantoni, senior director of single-family research and economics.

Builder Confidence Hits New High For 2005 - According to a survey by the National Association of Home Builders and Wells Fargo, "single-family home builders are more confident this June than they’ve been all year".

The most optimistic builders are in the West, where an HMI reading of 88 far outpaces that of builders in all other regions. Moreover, the 88 reading reflected a solid four-point gain from last month. Southern builders were also a bit more confident this time around, posting a one-point gain in their regional confidence gauge to 76 in June. Builders in the Northeast maintained a healthy, 70-point reading on the confidence scale, while builders in the Midwest registered a two-point confidence boost, to 52.

Check it out. Enjoy!

by Calculated Risk on 6/15/2005 06:35:00 PM

In a well coordinated attack, the Empire today unleashed a barrage of statistics and comments from in-house economists to poke holes in the silly notion of a "housing bubble". First up was Carl Steidtmann, chief economist of Deloitte Research:

"There has been much discussion recently about a housing bubble, but the truth is that home price appreciation has slowed considerably in the past three months. The time to talk about a bubble was last December," says Carl Steidtmann, chief economist of Deloitte Research and author of the monthly index.

"Consumer spending growth in the summer months will be largely dependent on the direction of home prices and job growth," continued Steidtmann. "As job growth continues to accelerate, we should see a corresponding pickup in real wage growth."

By this logic you should have worried about the Nasdaq bubble in the late '90s, but in March of 2000 everything was fine. Not the best investment strategy. And "job growth continues to accelerate"? The 3 month moving average of payroll growth (Seasonally adjusted from the BLS) shows job growth is at best flat after peaking in the Spring of 2004.

But that was just the beginning. The ubiquitous David Lereah responded to Fed Chairman Greenspan's recent remarks:

"Yes, there is froth in the markets, but froth can be healthy," said David Lereah, chief economist for the National Association of Realtors. "It's not a bad word."

Froth for a foamy latte or cappuccino might be good; froth in the housing market, especially when you are a new home buyer, is decidedly not good.

Economists representing members of the Washington, D.C.-based Homeownership Alliance, which includes a coalition of about 15 housing-related organizations, fired another salvo: See Housing boom won't let up.

Frank E. Nothaft, chief economist for mortgage industry giant Freddie Mac said "there are signs of 'suds' around the country" (good in your beer) but he is not worried:

"I think we'll see some gradual moderation in house-price valuation over the next couple of years," with about a one-in-three chance of a region in the country seeing stagnant or declining home values over the next couple of years, linked to regional economic weakness.

Paul Merski, chief economist for the Independent Community Bankers of America added:

"Bankers are being very diligent now about their lending practices," and the FDIC is "closely monitoring bankers' lending practices right now due to the long run in the housing boom."

"(The notion) of exotic products out there that are extremely dangerous is well overblown."

Since bankers are being very "diligent", I wonder why the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, the FED, the FDIC and other agencies took the highly unusual step of issuing new credit risk management guidance for home equity lending in May.

Merski also addressed the issue of home-price "froth." He said, "Economists have a saying that unsustainable trends will not be sustained," and that may hold true for some markets that have rapid, double-digit price appreciation. He forecast a "reasonable cooling off in certain markets in the prices but certainly no crashes in these markets because of the strong demand." Even so, the overall housing market should be strong for the rest of the year and going into 2006, he added.

No crashes. What a relief!

And finally, David W. Berson, chief economist for Fannie Mae added:

"There are no signs of any slowing in the housing market at all. You need a pretty good decline for the second half of the year not to set a record this year."

Those final comments are true; the housing market is still HOT.

For some reason I'm having the same reaction to all of these industry economists' comments as I do when the oil industry scientists assure me that global warming is not a problem. Maybe I need some suds!

by Calculated Risk on 6/15/2005 03:22:00 PM

The Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) released their weekly report today showing record purchase activity.

The seasonally-adjusted Purchase Index increased by 10.4 percent to 529.3, a record high, from 479.3 the previous week whereas the seasonally-adjusted Refinance Index increased by 25.6 percent to 2967.4 from 2362.1 one week earlier.

"This week there was a combination of record-setting purchase activity as well as a substantial pickup in refinance applications, with the refinance index at its highest level since April 2004," said Michael Fratantoni, senior director of single-family research and economics.

The use of ARMs decreased:

The adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) share of activity decreased to 30.9 percent of total applications from 31.7 percent the previous week.

Also, the National Association of Home Builders and Wells Fargo reported that home builders were optimistic:

"single-family home builders are more confident this June than they’ve been all year".

The most optimistic builders are in the West, where an HMI reading of 88 far outpaces that of builders in all other regions. Moreover, the 88 reading reflected a solid four-point gain from last month. Southern builders were also a bit more confident this time around, posting a one-point gain in their regional confidence gauge to 76 in June. Builders in the Northeast maintained a healthy, 70-point reading on the confidence scale, while builders in the Midwest registered a two-point confidence boost, to 52.

Meanwhile, DataQuick reported:

The sales pace of homes in Southern California eased back a notch in May as prices continued to climb to record levels, the result of steady demand and affordable mortgage financing, a real estate information service reported.

Although appreciation has slowed in some of the hot markets like San Diego, overall the housing market is still HOT!

by Calculated Risk on 6/15/2005 02:02:00 AM

Import traffic at the Port of Long Beach rose 6% over April, almost to the highs of last fall's heavy shipping season. The Port of Los Angeles will report in the next couple of days.

For Long Beach, the number of loaded inbound containers for MAY April was 288 thousand, up 6% from April and up 19% from May 2004. Outbound traffic was off 1% at 106 thousand containers, just below April's record.

And in a related story, the Port of Long Beach hosted the "Peak Season Forecast Conference" on Tuesday.

At the Pulse of the Ports conference, the experts forecast 2005 cargo gains of 10 to 15 percent. In preparation for this year's increase, they said they have added workers and equipment, and cargo has been moving smoothly.

"We may see two-to-three-day delays," during the peak season, said Frank Baragona of CMA CGM.

"We had one-week delays last year and that's not going to happen this year," said Doug Tilden of Marine Terminals.

This shipping data probably indicates near record imports from China. My very preliminary guess is that US imports from China will be over $19 Billion NSA for May compared to $18.12B for April 2005.

by Calculated Risk on 6/14/2005 06:40:00 PM

Dr. Thoma (Economist's View) and Barry Ritholtz (The Big Picture) discuss the Fed's path in the WSJ free feature "Where Will Rates Go From Here?"

Check it out!

by Calculated Risk on 6/14/2005 11:51:00 AM

Federal Reserve Governor Susan Schmidt Bies spoke on "Current Regulatory Issues" today in South Carolina. She touched on the housing market and credit risk issues in her speech to the North Carolina Bankers Association.

In particular, in the commercial and residential real estate sectors, we worry that borrowers could become increasingly speculative, buying beyond their means and hoping for asset price appreciation--whether they are buying for their own use or strictly for the sake of investment. We worry that competitive pressures could drive banks to lower their underwriting standards, implicitly encouraging such speculation. And we worry that, in the inevitable downturn, credit quality could deteriorate to the extent that some banks could experience significant losses.

The residential real estate sector has been experiencing a remarkable bull market, with home prices rising 11.2 percent last year--the fastest rate in more than a quarter-century. Along with the high home prices, we see indications that underwriting standards are beginning to weaken. For example, "affordability products"--such as interest-only loans, negative amortizations, and second mortgages with high loan-to-value ratios--are becoming more popular; subprime lending is growing faster than prime lending; adjustable-rate mortgages, or ARMs, have grown substantially and now account for more than a third of all mortgage originations, the highest level since 1994. Industry experts are increasingly concerned about the quality of collateral valuations relied upon in home equity lending and residential refinancing activities. More homes are being purchased not as primary dwellings, but as vacation homes or pure investments, in which case anticipated price appreciation may be a large factor influencing purchase decisions. According to the National Association of Realtors, purchases of second homes and purchases of residential real estate for investment purposes together accounted for almost 40 percent of all home purchases last year.

Given the vast growth in residential housing markets and the apparent slippage in underwriting standards in certain sectors, it is entirely appropriate for banking supervisors to seek to ensure that banks are employing proper risk-management practices. Last month, the federal banking agencies released guidance on credit-risk management for financial institutions' home equity lines of credit (HELOCs). The recent growth in HELOCs has been remarkable; at the end of 2004, outstanding drawn HELOCs at all insured commercial banks totaled $398 billion, a 40 percent increase over 2003. Meanwhile, the agencies have observed some easing of underwriting standards, with lenders competing to attract home equity lending business. Lenders are sometimes offering interest-only loans and are sometimes requiring very small down payments and limited documentation of a borrower's assets and income. They are also relying more on automated-valuation models and entering into more transactions with loan brokers and other third parties. Given this easing of standards, there is concern that portions of banks' home equity loan portfolios may be vulnerable to a rise in interest rates and a decline in home values. In other words, there is concern that not all banks fully recognize the embedded risks in some of their portfolios.

Also, Gavin sent me this commentary from Australia: Beware the bang if the property bubble bursts. It is possible that both the UK and Australia are leading indicators for the US housing market.